
Master of Reality
The Story
What They Thought Then
Sounds - August 14, 1971
Billy Walker
"as if tied by a piece of string to a post"
Walker argued that Tony Iommi sounded restricted on 'After Forever,' using the image to support contemporary criticism that the guitarist's range was limited.
Sounds - August 14, 1971
"sort of sadistic"
Walker reported this description from an American fan while explaining how Sabbath's heavy, repetitive sound connected with teenage listeners during the album's release.
Cash Box - August 28, 1971
"Surely this will be one of the year's top sellers."
The trade magazine made the album a Pop Pick, praising its gentler songs, Tony Iommi's instrumental writing and its continued appeal to fans of 'Paranoid.'
The Rag - September 20, 1971
Mike Saunders
"Black Sabbath grind out riff after riff after unrelenting riff"
Saunders praised the album's economy, contrasting Sabbath's concise riffing with the long, self-indulgent guitar solos he associated with Cream, Jeff Beck and Ten Years After.
Rolling Stone - November 25, 1971
Lester Bangs
"The only criterion is excitement, and Black Sabbath's got it."
Bangs treated repetition as a legitimate rock tradition, praised several songs, then questioned whether Sabbath could develop enough variation from album to album.
Creem - December 1, 1971
Dave Marsh
"I O.D.'d on Master of Reality awhile before he arrived"
Writing about listening sessions with Lester Bangs, Marsh said he had already played the album so heavily that he preferred letting Bangs put it on.
The Village Voice - December 12, 1971
Robert Christgau
"This is a dimwitted, amoral exploitation."
Christgau's Consumer Guide dismissed the band's audience and religious-occult politics, compared Sabbath unfavorably with Grand Funk and originally graded the album D.
